Why must I, the purchaser, pay the transfer fees, but the seller can choose the attorney?

17 September 2021
“I’m buying my first property. I’m quite nervous about everything and a friend of mine who is a conveyancer said she would help me with the transaction. However the seller is refusing and insisting that his attorneys must do the transfer. If I am the one paying the transfer fees, surely I should be able to nominate the attorney to do the transfer?”

As a rule of thumb our common law determines that a seller is the party entitled to nominate who the transferring attorney must be, given that the seller carries more risk than the purchaser. That said, nothing prohibits parties from agreeing that the purchaser can nominate the transferring attorney, although often in practice, the seller refuses to agree to such a condition and the purchaser then concedes for want of having the property.

Generally, it could be said that it makes more sense for the seller to nominate the transferring attorney as the purchaser is required to raise the purchase price, cover the transfer fees, meet suspensive conditions such as financing etc. and the seller would generally feel more protected by his attorney managing these important elements and ensure a speedy transaction and receipt of the purchase price. The transferring attorney has to ensure that the purchase price is secured and available and a purchaser’s attorney may be persuaded to rely upon assurances of his client that the money is available, with dire consequences for both purchaser and attorney, should this prove to be incorrect. In short, it is generally seen that the seller as the owner of the property to be transferred stands to lose more and therefore has a stronger claim to the appointment of the conveyancer.

Regardless, of who appoints the conveyancer, the conveyancer owes a duty of care to both parties and must represent both parties fairly, unless a dispute arises in which case the transferring attorney will be allowed to act on behalf of the party who  nominated him. It remains open for parties to negotiate the appointment of the transferring attorney and include a clause to such effect in the contract of sale and good grounds may exist which supports the purchaser being entitled to appoint the transferring attorney.

Who gets to choose the conveyancing attorney?

Who gets to choose the conveyancing attorney? 17 September 2021 “I’ve finally found a buyer for my property. I want my brother, who is an attorney, to do the transfer on the sale because then I know it will be done right and fast, but the buyer wants his attorney to...

Home Loan – What to do when you settle yours

Home Loan | ​What to do when you settle yours Home Loan Settlement can be a confusing process. We walk you through the Do's and Don'ts below. 17 September 2021 “After nearly 20 years I’m finally at the point where I’ve just about repaid my home loan. This has me...

Are you liable for historical arrear property rates on your property?

Are you liable for historical arrear property rates on your property?   17 September 2021Who is responsible for historical arrear property rates and taxes on your property? The good news is that the person who owned the property at the time the debt was incurred...

A strange thing called servitude

A strange thing called servitude 17 September 2021“I applied to my municipality to have the building plans for the extension of my garage approved. The municipality rejected my proposed extension on the grounds that it would be constructed over a servitude registered...

The previous owner did not pay. Can the municipality now cut off your electricity?

The previous owner did not pay. Can the municipality now cut off your electricity? 17 September 2021The municipality has notified me that it will disconnect my electricity supply because there are outstanding payments in respect of my property. However these...

Must I pay capital gains tax if I sell my house?

Must I pay capital gains tax if I sell my house?   17 September 2021“I bought my house, which I’ve always lived in since buying it, for about R1 million in 2000, and on my auditor’s advice had it appraised in October 2001 for R1.1 million. Over the years I had...

Beware the suspensive conditions in the offer to purchase

Beware the suspensive conditions in the offer to purchase 17 September 2021 “I’ve made a written offer on property that has been accepted by the seller. The offer was subject to the condition that I acquire a mortgage from a bank for the full purchase price within 30...

How about that ‘suspensive condition’?

​How about that ‘suspensive condition’? 10 September 2021 “I’ve bought and sold a few houses in my time and have always seen provision being made for a suspensive condition such as that the agreement is subject to a home loan being obtained. I’ve got the gist of what...

How to validly extend the period for getting your home loan approved

How to validly extend the period for getting your home loan approved 10 September 2021 “I’m trying to buy a house. The purchase agreement is subject to the condition that I obtain a mortgage bond within 30 days. My time is running out but I’m close to getting the...

What are the legal costs involved in buying a property?

What are the legal costs involved in buying a property? 10 September 2021   “My wife and I are considering buying a house. This is a big decision for us and we want to make sure we are financially prepared for all the costs and expenses involved in doing so. I...